Tradeify Order Types Explained: Market vs Limit vs Stop Orders on NinjaTrader

Order type mistakes cost Tradeify traders more money than bad trade ideas. I've watched traders pass their evaluations with solid strategy, then blow funded accounts because they used market orders during low liquidity, got slipped 15 ticks, and hit their trailing max drawdown on execution errors alone.

When you're trading Tradeify on NinjaTrader—whether via direct connection or through Tradovate credentials—you have access to multiple order types: market, limit, stop-market, stop-limit, MIT, and advanced bracket orders. Each has specific use cases, execution guarantees (or lack thereof), and risk profiles that directly impact whether you pass evaluations or fail on technicalities.

This guide breaks down every order type available on NinjaTrader for Tradeify traders, explains when to use each one, shows real examples of execution scenarios, and gives you the practical knowledge to avoid the order-type mistakes that kill accounts.

Quick heads-up: This article is based on my real experience with Tradeify and the info available when I published/updated this. Things change in prop trading — rules, payouts, promos, all of it.

For the absolute latest, check Tradeify´s website or their help center.

Why Order Types Matter on Tradeify

Unlike trading your own capital where a bad fill costs you a few bucks, on Tradeify a bad fill can:

• Blow through your daily loss limit (DLL) on Select accounts
• Trigger your trailing max drawdown before your stop would've hit
• Wreck your consistency percentage with unexpected losses
• Fail your evaluation or funded account on an execution error, not a strategy error

I've been trading Tradeify on NinjaTrader since launch, and the difference between traders who consistently pass evaluations and those who fail repeatedly often comes down to order execution discipline, not trading skill.

The Three Basic Order Types

1. Market Orders

What it is: An order that executes immediately at the best available price.

How it works:

• You click "Buy Market" or "Sell Market"
• Order goes to exchange
• Fills instantly against best available offer (buy) or bid (sell)
• No price guarantee—you get whatever price is available

When to use it:

• High-liquidity markets (ES, NQ during RTH)
• You need immediate execution and price isn't critical
• Exiting a position quickly (emergency stop or profit-taking)

When NOT to use it:

• Low-liquidity periods (overnight, pre-market, holidays)
• Volatile markets (news events, market opens/closes)
• Large position sizes that might move the market against you
• Any situation where slippage could violate Tradeify rules

Real example on Tradeify:You're long 2 NQ contracts at 18,500. Market suddenly drops, you panic, hit "Sell Market." NQ is currently at 18,485 bid / 18,485.25 ask. Your market order fills at 18,484.75 (half a point below the bid) because liquidity dried up in that millisecond.

Loss: 15.25 points × $20 × 2 contracts = $610 loss

If you were near your trailing drawdown limit, that extra half-point of slippage could've failed your account.

2. Limit Orders

What it is: An order that only executes at your specified price or better.

How it works:

• You specify the exact price you want
• Order sits in the market as a "working" order
• Only fills if price touches your limit price
• No fill guarantee—if price doesn't reach your limit, you don't get filled

When to use it:

• Entering positions at specific price levels
• Taking profits at predetermined targets
• Scalping where you need exact fills
• Any time you want price certainty over speed

When NOT to use it:

• Emergency exits (you might not get filled)
• Fast-moving markets (price may never touch your limit)
• Stop losses (use stop-market or stop-limit instead)

Real example on Tradeify:NQ is trading at 18,500. You want to enter long at 18,495. You place a Buy Limit at 18,495.

Scenario 1: NQ drops to 18,495, your order fills, NQ bounces to 18,510. Perfect entry.

Scenario 2: NQ drops to 18,496 and bounces immediately. Your order never filled—you missed the trade.

3. Stop-Market Orders (Stop Loss)

What it is: A conditional order that becomes a market order once your stop price is touched.

How it works:

• You set a "stop price"
• Order sits dormant until price touches your stop
• Once triggered, becomes a market order
• Fills at best available price (might be worse than your stop price)

When to use it:

• Stop losses for risk management
• Breakout entries (buy when price breaks above resistance)
• Trailing stops
• Any time you need guaranteed execution after a price level is hit

When NOT to use it:

• Fast-moving markets (you'll get slipped)
• Low liquidity (might fill much worse than expected)
• If exact exit price is critical (use stop-limit instead)

Real example on Tradeify:You're long 1 ES at 5800.00. You place a Sell Stop at 5795.00 as your stop loss.

Scenario 1 (Normal market):ES drops to 5795.00, your stop triggers, becomes a market order, fills at 5794.75. You lose 5.25 points × $50 = $262.50.

Scenario 2 (Fast market / news event):ES gaps down from 5796 to 5793 on news. Your stop at 5795 triggers, but because of the gap, your market order fills at 5792.50. You lose 7.5 points × $50 = $375 (50% more loss than expected).

This is why stop-market orders have execution guarantee but no price guarantee. You WILL get filled, but the price might suck.

Advanced Order Types

4. Stop-Limit Orders

What it is: A conditional order that becomes a limit order once your stop price is touched.

How it works:

• You set a "stop price" and a "limit price"
• Order activates when stop price is hit
• Then tries to fill at the limit price or better
• No fill guarantee—if price moves past your limit, you don't get filled

When to use it:

• When you want price control on stop exits
• Less volatile markets where you can control slippage
• Not recommended for stop losses (you might not get filled)

When NOT to use it:

• As a primary stop loss (risk of no fill = unlimited loss)
• Fast-moving markets
• Overnight risk management

Real example on Tradeify:You're long NQ at 18,500. You place a Sell Stop-Limit with Stop=18,490, Limit=18,489.

Scenario 1: NQ drops to 18,490 (triggers stop), market is trading 18,489.50 bid. Your limit order at 18,489 fills. You control slippage.

Scenario 2: NQ drops to 18,490, then gaps to 18,485 on a news spike. Your limit order at 18,489 never fills because price blew past it. You're still long NQ at 18,500 while it's trading at 18,485—now down 15 points ($300) instead of 10 points ($200).

My opinion: Don't use stop-limit for stop losses on Tradeify. The risk of not filling and blowing through your trailing drawdown is too high.

5. MIT (Market If Touched) Orders

What it is: Like a limit order, but converts to a market order when price is touched.

How it works:

• You set a "trigger price"
• When price touches your trigger, order becomes a market order
• Executes immediately at best available price

When to use it:

• Alternative to limit orders when you want guaranteed fill
• Breakout entries where you want immediate execution once level is hit

When NOT to use it:

• Same as market orders—avoid during low liquidity

Example:NQ is at 18,500. You want to enter long if it breaks above 18,510. You place Buy MIT at 18,510. When NQ touches 18,510, your order becomes a market order and fills immediately (might be 18,510.25 or 18,510.50 depending on liquidity).

Difference from limit order: Limit order might not fill if price moves fast. MIT guarantees fill once triggered.

6. OCO (One Cancels Other) Orders

What it is: Two linked orders where if one fills, the other automatically cancels.

How it works:

• You enter a position
• Set a profit target (limit) and stop loss (stop-market)
• Both orders are active
• Whichever hits first, the other cancels automatically

When to use it:

• Every single trade on Tradeify (seriously)
• Bracket orders (NinjaTrader's ATM strategy uses OCO)
• Any time you want automated risk management

Example on NinjaTrader:You buy 1 NQ at 18,500 using an ATM strategy:

• Profit target: 18,515 (limit order)
• Stop loss: 18,490 (stop-market order)

If NQ hits 18,515, profit target fills and stop loss cancels automatically. If NQ drops to 18,490, stop fills and profit target cancels. You never risk having both orders execute (which would create a hedge violation on Tradeify).

More on Tradeify's hedging rules here.

NinjaTrader ATM Strategies (Advanced Trade Management)

NinjaTrader's ATM (Advanced Trade Management) feature is the best tool for managing Tradeify accounts. Here's how it works:

What Is an ATM Strategy?

An ATM strategy is a predefined set of orders that automatically execute when you enter a trade:

• Entry: You place your initial order
• Profit Target: Auto-placed as a limit order
• Stop Loss: Auto-placed as a stop-market order
• Trailing Stop: Optional—moves your stop as price moves in your favor

How to Set Up an ATM Strategy on NinjaTrader

1. Right-click chart → ATM Strategy → Create ATM Strategy
2. Name your strategy (e.g., "Tradeify 10pt NQ")
3. Set profit target: 10 points (on NQ = $200 profit)
4. Set stop loss: 5 points (on NQ = $100 risk)
5. Optional trailing stop: Move stop up 1 tick for every 2 ticks of profit
6. Save template

Now every time you take a trade:

1. Select your ATM strategy from dropdown
2. Place entry order (market, limit, or stop)
3. NinjaTrader auto-places profit target and stop loss
4. Both are OCO-linked (one fills, other cancels)

Why ATM Strategies Are Critical for Tradeify

Reason 1: SpeedYou can't manually place stop loss and profit target fast enough. By the time you place your entry and then fumble to place stops, price might've moved against you. ATM does it instantly.

Reason 2: ConsistencyEvery trade has the same risk management structure. No "I'll just watch this one" trades that blow your account.

Reason 3: Emotion ControlYour stops are placed automatically. You can't "give it more room" or move stops mid-trade. This protects you from emotional decisions.

I've been using ATM strategies on my Tradeify accounts since day one. Every trade has pre-set stops and targets. It's one of the reasons I've maintained multiple payouts across my accounts.

Real-World Order Type Scenarios on Tradeify

Scenario 1: Scalping ES During RTH

Setup:

• Trading ES during regular hours (9:30 AM - 4:00 PM ET)
• High liquidity
• Looking for 2-4 point scalps

Order types to use:

• Entry: Market order or limit order 1 tick below ask (for buys)
• Stop loss: Stop-market order 4 points away
• Profit target: Limit order 2 points away

Why:

• Liquidity is high, market orders fill cleanly
• Stop-market ensures you get out if wrong
• Limit order on target captures exact exit price

Scenario 2: Swing Trading NQ Overnight

Setup:

• Entering position at 4:00 PM, holding overnight
• Lower liquidity after hours
• Targeting 20-30 point move

Order types to use:

• Entry: Limit order at specific level (don't chase with market)
• Stop loss: Stop-market with wider buffer (10-15 points)
• Profit target: Limit order or trailing stop to capture move

Why:

• Overnight spreads are wider—limit entry controls slippage
• Wider stops account for overnight volatility
• Trailing stop captures extended moves without constant monitoring

Scenario 3: Trading a News Event (NFP, FOMC)

Setup:

• Major news release at 8:30 AM or 2:00 PM
• Extreme volatility expected
• Quick directional move likely

Order types to use:

• DO NOT USE MARKET ORDERS (you'll get destroyed on slippage)
• Entry: Limit order or wait for initial spike to settle
• Stop loss: Stop-market with 2x your normal distance
• Profit target: Limit order or manual exit watching Level 2

Why:

• Spreads widen dramatically during news
• Market orders can slip 10-20 ticks easily
• Better to miss the trade than get terrible fills

Note: Tradeify has news trading restrictions on certain high-impact events. Check their rules before trading NFP or FOMC.

Common Order Type Mistakes That Fail Tradeify Accounts

Mistake #1: Using Market Orders During Low Liquidity

What happens:Trader uses market orders at 3:00 AM on Sunday when futures just opened. Gets slipped 8 ticks on entry, another 8 on exit. That's 16 ticks of slippage on a round trip trade = $200 gone before the trade even had a chance.

Fix:Use limit orders during overnight sessions, early morning, and low-volume periods.

Mistake #2: No Stop Loss Because "I'll Watch It"

What happens:Trader enters long without placing a stop, planning to "manually exit if it goes against me." Gets distracted, checks phone, looks back 10 minutes later and position is down 30 points. Account blown.

Fix:Use ATM strategies. ALWAYS have a stop-market order in place before entry.

Mistake #3: Stop-Limit on Stop Loss (No Fill)

What happens:Trader uses stop-limit instead of stop-market for stop loss. Price gaps through the limit, order never fills, position keeps bleeding. Trader hits trailing max drawdown before realizing they're still in the trade.

Fix:Use stop-market for stop losses, not stop-limit. Accept some slippage in exchange for guaranteed fills.

Mistake #4: Fat-Finger Orders (Wrong Price or Quantity)

What happens:Trader means to buy 1 NQ contract, accidentally types 10. Position immediately goes against them for 5 points. Loss: 5 points × $20 × 10 contracts = $1,000. Account fails on a typo.

Fix:Use ATM strategy templates with predefined position sizes. Double-check quantity before hitting submit.

Order Entry Tools in NinjaTrader

NinjaTrader gives you multiple ways to place orders:

My setup on Tradeify:I use Chart Trader with ATM strategies. I place entries by clicking on the chart (visual and fast), and my ATM strategy auto-places stops and targets. This gives me speed, visual feedback, and automated risk management in one workflow.

Full setup guide: NinjaTrader 8 setup for Tradeify.

FAQ

Q: What's the best order type for stop losses on Tradeify?Stop-market. It guarantees you get out of the trade even if you get slipped a tick or two. Stop-limit risks not filling, which can blow your account.

Q: Should I use market orders or limit orders for entries on Tradeify?Depends on liquidity. During RTH on ES or NQ, market orders are fine. During overnight or low-volume periods, use limit orders to control slippage.

Q: Can I use trailing stops on Tradeify accounts?Yes. Trailing stops are allowed and highly effective for capturing extended moves. Set them up in NinjaTrader's ATM strategy menu.

Q: What happens if my stop-market order fills worse than expected—does Tradeify care?No. Tradeify doesn't care why you lost money, only that you lost it. If your stop-market slips 10 ticks and hits your DLL or drawdown, the account fails regardless of whether it was slippage or a bad trade.

Q: Do I need to use OCO orders on Tradeify?Not required, but highly recommended. OCO ensures your profit target and stop loss are linked. If one fills, the other cancels automatically, preventing hedging violations or over-execution.

Q: Can I change my order type mid-trade on NinjaTrader?Yes. You can cancel an existing order and replace it with a different type. But this creates execution risk—better to place the right order type initially.

Q: Does Tradeify have order type restrictions?No. You can use any order type NinjaTrader supports. But some order types (like stop-limit) are riskier for account management than others (stop-market).

Q: How do I avoid fat-finger errors on large orders?Use ATM strategy templates with predefined position sizes. Set up separate templates for 1, 2, and 3 contract trades. This prevents typing errors.

Q: What's the difference between a stop-loss order and a stop-limit order on Tradeify?Stop-loss (stop-market) guarantees fill but not price. Stop-limit guarantees price but not fill. For risk management, use stop-market.

Conclusion

Order type discipline is the difference between traders who pass Tradeify evaluations consistently and those who blow accounts on execution mistakes. Market orders, limit orders, stop-market orders, and OCO brackets aren't just technicalities—they're the mechanical foundation of risk management.

I've been trading Tradeify on NinjaTrader since launch, and every one of my funded accounts uses ATM strategies with pre-defined stops and targets. I don't trust myself to place stops manually. I don't use market orders during low liquidity. I don't use stop-limits for risk management.

The traders who succeed on Tradeify are the ones who treat order execution as seriously as trade selection. They understand slippage costs. They know when to prioritize speed (market orders) vs price (limit orders). They automate their risk management with ATM strategies so emotions don't interfere.

If you're serious about passing evaluations and scaling to Elite Live accounts, master order types. They're not optional—they're essential.

Your Next Steps

‍👉 Start Trading at Tradeify Today

‍👉 Read My Full Tradeify Review

‍👉 Check out Tradeify´s Select Plans

‍

‍

‍

‍