TakeProfitTrader vs Lucid Trading: Complete 2026 Comparison

‍Quick Take: TakeProfitTrader and Lucid Trading both offer one-step futures evaluations with no monthly subscription traps, but they're built for completely different trader types.

TPT's been around since March 2021—battle-tested, 4,500+ Trustpilot reviews, proven payout track record.

Lucid launched in early 2025—new player moving fast with 816+ reviews at 4.8/5 and already $2M+ paid out. TPT uses EOD drawdown in Test that switches to brutal intraday trailing in PRO (60% of negative reviews cite this), back to EOD in PRO+. Lucid uses EOD trailing everywhere with a scaling daily loss limit that grows as you profit.

TPT charges $119-$252/month for eval with $130 activation (waived with promos), offers 80/20 split (90/10 in PRO+), 24-48hr payouts. Lucid charges $60-$275 one-time fee with $0 activation forever, offers 90/10 split (legacy accounts got 100% first $10K), ~15 minute payouts—fastest in the industry. TPT caps you at 5 accounts; Lucid also 5.

But here's the kicker: Lucid's LucidFlex account (launched late 2025) has NO daily loss limit in eval, NO consistency rule in funded, and NO buffer requirement for payouts. TPT's PRO intraday trailing will liquidate you on winner reversals. Lucid's EOD drawdown forgives intraday volatility but the scaling DLL can surprise you if you're not watching it.

This isn't about which firm is "better"—it's about whether you need speed (Lucid's 15-min payouts destroy TPT's 24-48hr), flexibility (Lucid's three account types vs TPT's two), or proven longevity (TPT's 4-year track record vs Lucid's sub-1-year existence). Choose based on your risk tolerance for new firms, whether you can handle intraday drawdown tracking, and how fast you need your money.

Evaluation Structure: One-Step Showdown

Both firms use single-phase evaluations—no multi-step bureaucracy. But the rule differences determine who passes and who blows accounts in the first week.

Key Observation: Lucid's LucidFlex account is a game-changer—no daily loss limit in evaluation, no consistency rule in funded phase, and no buffer requirement for payouts. This is the cleanest futures eval structure on the market right now. TPT's 50% consistency in Test is more forgiving than most firms, but the PRO intraday trailing switcheroo kills 60% of traders who pass Test.

Pricing Breakdown: One-Time vs Subscription

This is where Lucid destroys TPT on upfront costs—but you need to understand the trade-off between paying more now vs paying monthly.

Real-World Cost Comparison ($50K Account):

Scenario 1: You pass in 1 month

• TPT: Pay $119 first month. Pass. Pay $0 activation. Get $119 refunded in first withdrawal. Total cost: $0.
• Lucid: Pay $80 one-time (LucidPro with promo). Pass. Pay $0 activation. Total cost: $80.
• Winner: TPT by $80 if you pass in first month.

Scenario 2: You take 3 months to pass

• TPT: Pay $119/month × 3 = $357. Pass on month 3. Pay $0 activation. Get $119 refunded (first month only). Total cost: $238.
• Lucid: Pay $80 one-time. Pass whenever. Pay $0 activation. Total cost: $80.
• Winner: Lucid by $158.

Scenario 3: You fail twice and reset

• TPT: Pay $119 first month + $100 reset + $100 reset = $319. Then another $119/month until you pass (let's say 1 more month). Total cost: $438 (assuming 2 months total trading + 2 resets).
• Lucid: Pay $80 first eval + ~$80 reset + ~$80 reset = $240. Total cost: $240.
• Winner: Lucid by $198.

Verdict: If you're a killer trader who passes in 5-10 days, TPT's NOFEE40 promo makes it free. If you're learning and might take 2-4 months or need resets, Lucid's one-time payment saves hundreds. Lucid also wins on predictability—you know your max cost upfront.

Critical Difference #1: Drawdown Mechanics (EOD vs Intraday Tracking)

This is the #1 reason traders pass one firm and fail the other. The drawdown model determines whether your trading style survives.

TakeProfitTrader: The Drawdown Switcheroo That Kills 60% of PRO Traders

TPT uses three different drawdown models depending on account phase:

1. Test Phase (Evaluation): End-of-day (EOD) trailing drawdown. Updates once at 5 PM ET. You can be down $4K intraday on a $50K account, claw back to -$800 by close, and you're fine as long as you close above $47K (your trailing threshold). Forgiving for volatile intraday moves.
2. PRO Phase (Simulated Funded): Switches to intraday trailing drawdown. Tracks real-time with unrealized P&L. If you're up $1K unrealized, your minimum moves to $51K. Give back $1.3K and drop to $49.7K? Liquidated—even though you're still $700 above starting balance and never closed below it. This is cited in 60% of TPT's negative Trustpilot reviews as the failure reason.
3. PRO+ Phase (Live Funded): Returns to EOD trailing drawdown. You get breathing room again, but qualifying requires $5K in PRO profits frozen as collateral (controversial—see profit split section).

Example: $50K PRO account, $52K balance (buffer met), $50K minimum. You go long 4 ES at 5,950. Market spikes to 5,962—you're up $2,400 unrealized. Your minimum is now $52.4K. Market reverses hard. You're still holding (tight stop didn't trigger yet). Balance drops to $52.1K. Account liquidated. You're $2.1K above starting balance, but you violated your new real-time minimum by $300.

Who survives TPT PRO: Scalpers who close winners within seconds/minutes. Traders who set profit targets at +5-8 ES points and exit religiously. Anyone willing to take 70% of a winner off and trail the rest with a breakeven stop.

Who gets wrecked: Swing traders holding for hours. Traders who "let winners run" and give back 50% of moves on reversals. Anyone using wide stops (15+ points on ES).

Lucid Trading: EOD Drawdown Everywhere (But Watch the Scaling DLL)

Lucid uses end-of-day trailing drawdown on all account types. Your drawdown recalculates at market close only. Intraday swings don't liquidate you as long as you close above your threshold.

But there's a twist: Daily Loss Limit (DLL) that scales with your performance:

• Fixed DLL initially: $50K = $1,200 max daily loss, $100K = $1,800. If you hit this in a single session, you're locked out until next day (account doesn't fail—you just can't trade until reset).
• LucidScale DLL (after you profit): Once you close above your "Initial Trail Balance" (starting balance + a bit), the fixed DLL is replaced by: LucidScale DLL = 60% of your highest EOD profit. So if your best end-of-day closing profit is $2,000, your new DLL is $1,200. Hit $1,200 loss in a day, locked out until tomorrow.

LucidFlex Exception: Launched late 2025, LucidFlex has NO daily loss limit in evaluation or funded phase. Only the 4% EOD trailing matters. This is massive—you can lose $3K intraday on a $50K account, recover to -$500 by close, and you're fine. The cleanest rule set in futures prop trading right now.

Example: $50K Lucid LucidPro account, $53K balance (hit profit target), $51K threshold (4% EOD trailing), $1,200 fixed DLL. You take 3 bad trades today—down $1,500 at one point. But you close at $52.2K. Are you liquidated? No. Your EOD balance ($52.2K) is above your threshold ($51K). You're fine. But you exceeded your $1,200 DLL—tomorrow you can't trade until it resets.

Who survives Lucid: Swing traders who hold positions for hours. Traders with wider stops (12-20 ES points). Anyone who lets winners breathe during intraday pullbacks. Especially LucidFlex users—no DLL means complete freedom.

Who gets wrecked: Traders who forget about the DLL and blow $2K in a morning session thinking they have all day to recover. Traders who don't realize the DLL scales up to 60% of their best day (if your best close was +$5K, your DLL is now $3K—seems great until you hit it).

Critical Difference #2: Profit Split & Payout Structure

Both firms advertise competitive splits, but the payout speed difference is massive—and Lucid's legacy accounts had a unique profit structure.

TakeProfitTrader: 80/20 → 90/10, But $5K Gets Frozen

• PRO accounts (simulated): 80/20 split in your favor. Withdraw from day one above buffer. $50K account needs $52K before first withdrawal ($2K buffer = your drawdown). Processing: 24 hours to TPT wallet, 12 hours to bank = 36-48 hours total.
• PRO+ accounts (live): 90/10 split. EOD drawdown returns. No buffer—withdraw from $50,001 on day one. Qualification paths:
  • Path 1: $10K profit in single day (invitation within 24-48hrs).
  • Path 2: $5K total profit in PRO, which gets frozen as collateral. Your PRO+ starts at $50K with $48K minimum (because $2K was already buffer). The remaining $3K is locked working capital. You get 90% of PRO+ profits + 80% of the frozen $5K when you close PRO+.

This $5K freeze pisses traders off. They expected: "Make $5K in PRO → withdraw it → get fresh PRO+ account." Reality: "$5K becomes locked capital you can't touch until you quit PRO+."

No consistency rule in PRO or PRO+. Once you pass Test, you can have uneven profit days without penalty. This is a huge advantage over firms that enforce consistency in funded accounts.

Example TPT Payout:

• PRO account, $50K starting, $54K balance (buffer met + $2K profit above buffer).
• Withdraw $2K. You keep 80% = $1,600. TPT keeps 20% = $400.
• Processing: 36-48 hours to your bank.
• Second withdrawal (another $1K above buffer): Keep 80% = $800. Total in your pocket: $2,400.

Lucid Trading: 90/10 Everywhere, ~15 Minute Payouts (Fastest in Industry)

• All funded accounts: 90/10 split in your favor. Legacy accounts (purchased before Nov 28, 2025) kept 100% of first $10K, then 90/10. This was a massive perk—extra $1K per account vs straight 90/10 firms.
• New accounts (after Nov 28, 2025): Straight 90/10 from dollar one. Lucid removed the 100% first $10K bonus.

Payout speed: Lucid's defining feature. Payouts approved within minutes (often 15 minutes or less per reviews). Funds hit your bank in 2 business days, but approval is instant. Compare to TPT's 36-48 hour processing—Lucid is 24-32 hours faster.

Consistency rules vary by account:

• LucidPro (new accounts): 40% max (was 35% before Nov 28, 2025). Best day can't exceed 40% of total profits during payout cycle. Example: If your best day is $1,600 and total profit is $4,000, you're at 40%—compliant. If total is only $3,000, you're at 53%—denied.
• LucidDirect: 20% max. Stricter than LucidPro because it's instant funding without eval.
• LucidFlex: NO consistency rule. Zero. You can make $3K on day one and $100 over the next week, request payout, and it's approved. This is revolutionary.

Payout requirements:

• LucidPro: 5 profitable trading days per cycle meeting minimum thresholds ($50K = $150/day min). Plus you need to maintain a "buffer" (Initial Max Loss Limit + $100). $50K account buffer = $2,100. So you need $52,100 balance before you can withdraw anything.
• LucidFlex: 5 profitable days meeting thresholds ($50K = $150/day), positive net profit in cycle (even $1 qualifies), NO buffer requirement. You can withdraw from $50,001 on day 6 if you have 5 profitable days.
• LucidDirect: 8 trading days first payout, 8 days between subsequent payouts.

Payout caps: Lucid caps withdrawal amounts by cycle number to protect against blowup risk:

• $50K LucidPro: $1,500 on payouts 1-2, $2,000 on 3-4, $2,500 on 5-6.
• $50K LucidFlex: 50% of profit, capped at $2,000 per payout.

After 6 successful payouts, you transition to LucidLive (real capital, swing trading allowed, overnight holds permitted, real broker account).

Example Lucid Payout:

• LucidFlex $50K account, $52K balance, 5 profitable days completed, $2K profit above starting.
• Request $2K payout (50% of profit = $1K, but you can request up to $2K cap).
• You keep 90% = $1,800. Lucid keeps 10% = $200.
• Approved in 15 minutes. Funds hit bank in 1-2 business days.

Verdict: Lucid destroys TPT on payout speed. 15 minutes vs 36-48 hours is massive for traders who need fast liquidity. TPT's lack of consistency rule in PRO/PRO+ is a hidden gem—uneven profits are fine. Lucid's LucidFlex matches this (no consistency) while also removing the buffer requirement. For pure payout efficiency, LucidFlex is the cleanest structure in futures prop trading right now.

Platform Flexibility: 15+ vs 8 Core Options

Platform support determines whether you keep your muscle memory or spend weeks relearning.

TakeProfitTrader: Maximum Flexibility (15+ Platforms)

TPT supports 15+ platforms through CQG and Rithmic data feeds:

• NinjaTrader 8 (most popular)
• TradingView (web-based, mobile-friendly)
• Tradovate (TradingView integration)
• Quantower (advanced footprint/order flow)
• MotiveWave (Elliott Wave specialists)
• R|Trader (Rithmic native)
• ATAS (volume analysis)
• Sierra Chart (institutional-grade)
• BookMap (heatmap liquidity visualization)
• Plus: EdgeClear, Jigsaw, Investor/RT, MultiCharts, Optimus Flow, Rhythm

Platform costs: You pay data feeds separately. Rithmic CME data ~$55/month. CQG varies by exchange. TPT doesn't bundle these—you pay providers directly.

Copy trading: Allowed on all platforms using external tools (Tradesyncer, Replikanto, Duplicate Account Actions). Run up to 5 PRO/PRO+ accounts with copy setups.

Lucid Trading: 8 Core Platforms (Everything Included)

Lucid supports 8 platforms with different availability by account type:

• Rithmic (all accounts)
• Tradovate (all accounts)
• Project X (LucidPro/LucidDirect only—NOT LucidFlex)
• Quantower (all accounts)
• MotiveWave (all accounts)
• NinjaTrader (all accounts)
• Sierra Chart (all accounts)
• TradingView (all accounts)

Platform costs: Included in your one-time fee. No separate data charges, no license fees. What you pay upfront is all you pay.

Copy trading: Allowed across up to 5 funded accounts using external tools.

Critical note: LucidFlex (the newest, cleanest account type) is NOT available on Project X. If you're a Project X devotee, you're stuck with LucidPro or LucidDirect.

Verdict: TPT wins on variety (15+ vs 8), but Lucid covers the most-used platforms. If you're using an exotic tool like ATAS, EdgeClear, or Jigsaw, TPT is your only option. If you're on NinjaTrader, Sierra, Quantower, or TradingView, both firms work—and Lucid's bundled costs are cleaner.

Pass Rates & Success Reality: The Brutal Truth

Neither firm publishes official pass rates for 2026, but we can estimate from reviews and community data.

TakeProfitTrader Pass Rates

• 2023 (Jan-Aug): 20.37% of Test accounts passed to PRO
• 2024 (Jan-Dec): 16.86% of Test accounts passed to PRO
• PRO to PRO+ transition: Less than 10% estimated (no official stat)

Why traders fail:

1. Intraday trailing in PRO: 60% of negative reviews cite this. Traders pass Test with EOD drawdown, then get wrecked by real-time tracking in PRO.
2. 50% consistency in Test: Forces continued trading after one big win to dilute the percentage. Punishes efficient setups.
3. Emotional trading: Letting winners reverse, revenge trading, overleveraging after early success.

Pass rate declining: TPT's pass rate dropped from 20.37% (2023) to 16.86% (2024). Could be harder trader base, could be PRO intraday drawdown filtering more people out.

Lucid Trading Pass Rates

• Estimated 15-25% based on 816 Trustpilot reviews at 4.8/5 rating and community sentiment analysis. No official disclosure.
• LucidFlex likely higher: No DLL in eval, no consistency rule, 4% profit target (vs 6% on LucidPro)—should have 25-35% pass rate estimated.

Why traders fail:

1. Scaling DLL surprise: Traders don't realize the DLL jumps to 60% of best day once they profit. Best close was +$3K? Your DLL is now $1.8K. Hit it in one session, locked out rest of day.
2. 35-40% consistency on LucidPro: Tighter than TPT's 50%. One $2K day followed by $3K total profit = 67%—denied payout even though you passed eval.
3. Buffer requirement on LucidPro: $50K needs $52.1K before first withdrawal. Traders hit profit target at $53K, try to withdraw, denied because they're only $900 above buffer.

Lucid's advantage: Fast activation after passing. Reviews consistently mention "passed evaluation, activated to Pro account same day" or "within 5-30 minutes." TPT takes 1-2 business days for PRO activation.

Company Longevity & Trust: 4 Years vs 9 Months

This matters more than traders think. Prop firms fold frequently—especially new ones.

TakeProfitTrader: Battle-Tested (March 2021 - Present)

• Founded: March 2021 by James Sixsmith
• Track record: 4 years, 9 months operating
• Trustpilot: 4,500+ reviews, 4.3/5 average
• Payouts: Millions paid out (no specific disclosure)
• Stability: No major scandals, no sudden rule changes that screwed traders, consistent payout processing

Red flags: Some traders report tickets disappearing from system, 3-4 day support delays during high volume. But these are operational hiccups, not existential threats.

Lucid Trading: New Player Moving Fast (Early 2025 - Present)

• Founded: Early 2025 by CEO AJ Campanella
• Track record: Less than 1 year operating (launched ~Q1 2025)
• Trustpilot: 816+ reviews, 4.8/5 average (higher rating, fewer reviews)
• Payouts: $2M+ disclosed, 5,000+ traders served
• Stability: Too new to judge. No scandals yet, but also no multi-year track record.

Concerns: New firms are higher risk. They could:

1. Run out of capital if too many traders succeed simultaneously
2. Change rules mid-stream to reduce payouts
3. Fold if business model doesn't work

Positive signs: Lucid's 4.8/5 rating with 816 reviews is exceptional. Reviews consistently praise speed, support, and transparency. They're paying out fast (15-min approvals) without delays—suggests healthy cash flow.

Verdict: TPT is the "safe" choice—proven track record, 4+ years of consistent payouts, established reputation. Lucid is the "high-upside" choice—better rules (LucidFlex especially), faster payouts, but higher firm risk due to age. If you're risk-averse, TPT's longevity wins. If you're comfortable with new-firm risk for better terms, Lucid delivers.

Who Each Firm Is Best For: Make the Right Choice

These firms serve different trader profiles. Choose based on experience, trading style, and risk tolerance—not which one has cooler marketing.

✅ TakeProfitTrader Is Best For:

1. Risk-averse traders who value proven longevity. 4+ years operating, millions paid out, no major scandals. You know TPT will be here in 12 months.
2. Platform specialists using ATAS, EdgeClear, Jigsaw, BookMap, or other exotic tools. TPT's 15+ platform support preserves your edge. Lucid doesn't support these.
3. Traders comfortable adapting to intraday trailing in PRO. If you can close winners aggressively (take 70% off at target, trail the rest with breakeven stop), TPT PRO works. The 80/20 split and 24-48hr payouts are solid.
4. Traders who want no consistency rule in funded accounts. Once you hit PRO, make $5K on Monday and $200 the rest of the week—doesn't matter. No payout denials for uneven profits.
5. Traders who pass evaluations quickly (5-15 days). TPT's NOFEE40 promo makes it literally $0 cost if you pass in first month and get the refund. Can't beat free.
6. Traders who don't need instant payout speed. If 36-48 hours is fine and you don't need liquidity within minutes, TPT's established reputation trumps Lucid's speed advantage.

❌ TakeProfitTrader Is NOT For:

1. Swing traders who hold positions for 2-6 hours. TPT's PRO intraday trailing will liquidate you on normal retracements. If you go +$2K unrealized, then -$1.5K on a pullback before recovering, you're dead.
2. Traders who let winners ride. The "set and forget" mentality with wide stops doesn't survive PRO's real-time drawdown tracking.
3. News traders. FOMC/NFP/CPI blackouts with 1-min buffer in PRO/PRO+ eliminate high-volatility setups. Lucid allows all news trading.
4. Traders who need fast payouts. If you're running 3-5 accounts and withdrawing weekly, TPT's 36-48hr processing is slow compared to Lucid's 15-min approvals.
5. Beginners. TPT's 16.86% pass rate (2024) is brutal for learning traders. The PRO intraday drawdown switch will blindside you if you don't understand real-time tracking.
6. Traders who take 2-4 months to pass. TPT's monthly subscription bleeds $119-$252/month. Lucid's one-time fee caps your cost at $80-$275 regardless of time.

✅ Lucid Trading Is Best For:

1. Traders who value payout speed above everything. ~15 minute approvals destroy TPT's 36-48 hours. If you need fast liquidity to compound across accounts or cover living expenses, Lucid wins.
2. Swing traders and position holders. Lucid's EOD drawdown everywhere gives breathing room for intraday volatility. Hold an ES runner from 10 AM to 2 PM, give back 8 points on a consolidation, recover 12 points by close—you're fine.
3. News traders. Lucid allows FOMC/NFP/CPI trading with zero restrictions on all account types. If high-volatility events are your edge, Lucid is the only choice between these two.
4. Traders who want the cleanest rules (LucidFlex). No DLL in eval, no consistency rule in funded, no buffer requirement for payouts, only 4% profit target. This is the most trader-friendly futures eval structure on the market right now.
5. Traders who take time to pass (2-6 months). Lucid's one-time payment caps your cost. Pay $80-$275 once, take 6 months to pass if you need it—no monthly bleeding.
6. Traders comfortable with new-firm risk. If you're okay with Lucid's <1 year track record in exchange for better rules and faster payouts, the upside is massive.

❌ Lucid Trading Is NOT For:

1. Risk-averse traders who need proven longevity. Lucid launched in early 2025—less than 1 year operating. If you're paranoid about new firms folding, TPT's 4-year track record is safer.
2. Traders using Project X who want LucidFlex. LucidFlex (the best account type) is NOT available on Project X. You're stuck with LucidPro or LucidDirect if you insist on Project X.
3. Traders using ATAS, EdgeClear, Jigsaw, or exotic platforms. Lucid only supports 8 platforms. If your edge depends on specialized tools, TPT's 15+ platform support is non-negotiable.
4. Traders who forget about the scaling DLL. If you make $5K your best day, your DLL jumps to $3K (60% of best day). Hit $3K loss in a session, you're locked out. If you're not monitoring this, you'll get surprised.
5. Traders who can't handle the LucidPro buffer. $50K needs $52.1K before first withdrawal. If you hit $53K profit target and try to withdraw $1K, denied—you're only $900 above buffer. Use LucidFlex instead (no buffer).
6. Traders who want 100% of first $10K. Legacy accounts had this perk (purchased before Nov 28, 2025). New accounts are straight 90/10. If you wanted that bonus, you're 3+ weeks too late.

Direct Head-to-Head: The Final Verdict

There's no universal "better" firm. The right choice depends on what you value most.

Choose TakeProfitTrader if:

• ✅ You value proven longevity (4+ years vs <1 year)
• ✅ You use exotic platforms (ATAS, EdgeClear, Jigsaw, BookMap)
• ✅ You can adapt to intraday trailing in PRO after EOD eval in Test
• ✅ You want no consistency rule in funded accounts (uneven profits are fine)
• ✅ You pass evaluations fast (5-15 days = $0 cost with NOFEE40 promo)
• ✅ 36-48hr payouts are acceptable (you don't need instant liquidity)

Avoid TakeProfitTrader if:

• ❌ You're a swing trader who holds for hours (PRO intraday trailing kills you)
• ❌ You let winners ride with wide stops (normal retracements liquidate PRO accounts)
• ❌ You're a news trader (FOMC/NFP/CPI blackouts eliminate setups)
• ❌ You need fast payouts (15 min vs 36-48 hrs is massive for weekly withdrawals)
• ❌ You take 2-4 months to pass (monthly subscription bleeds capital)
• ❌ You're a beginner (16.86% pass rate + PRO drawdown switch will wreck you)

Choose Lucid Trading if:

• ✅ You value payout speed (~15 min approvals, fastest in industry)
• ✅ You're a swing trader who holds intraday (EOD drawdown everywhere forgives volatility)
• ✅ You're a news trader (zero restrictions on FOMC/NFP/CPI)
• ✅ You want LucidFlex (no DLL, no consistency, no buffer—cleanest rules)
• ✅ You take time to pass (one-time payment caps cost at $80-$275 regardless of months)
• ✅ You're comfortable with new-firm risk (better rules, but <1 year track record)

Avoid Lucid Trading if:

• ❌ You're risk-averse about new firms (launched early 2025, no multi-year proof)
• ❌ You use Project X + want LucidFlex (Flex not available on Project X)
• ❌ You use exotic platforms (ATAS, EdgeClear, Jigsaw not supported)
• ❌ You forget about scaling DLL (jumps to 60% of best day, can surprise you)
• ❌ You can't handle buffer on LucidPro ($50K needs $52.1K for first payout)

My Take: Which One Would I Use?

If I'm being honest, I'd run both—but prioritized differently based on my trading evolution.

If I'm experienced (2+ years profitable on own capital) and want to scale fast:
→ Lucid LucidFlex. Pay $65-$221 one-time (with promo), get the cleanest eval on the market (no DLL, 4% profit target, EOD drawdown), pass in 7-12 days, then enjoy no consistency rule + no buffer requirement in funded phase. ~15 minute payout approvals mean I can withdraw Monday morning, reinvest in another Lucid account Monday afternoon. Run 3-5 LucidFlex accounts with copy trading. Risk: Lucid is <1 year old—if they fold, I lose accounts. But the speed and rule set are unmatched.

If I'm intermediate (6-18 months, still building consistency) and value safety:
→ TakeProfitTrader Test. Use NOFEE40 promo to get $0 activation + first month refund. Pass Test in 15-20 days using EOD drawdown (forgiving), then carefully adapt to PRO intraday trailing by taking profits aggressively. TPT's 4-year track record is safer for my learning phase. Once I'm confident in PRO, I'd branch into Lucid for faster payouts.

If I'm a news trader or swing trader who holds 2-4 hours:
→ Lucid LucidFlex only. TPT's PRO intraday trailing would kill my style. Lucid's EOD drawdown + zero news restrictions + no DLL (on Flex) = perfect fit. I'd pay the $65-$221 one-time, pass in 10-15 days, and never look at TPT.

If I'm paranoid about new firms and need absolute safety:
→ TakeProfitTrader. Lucid's <1 year existence is too risky if I'm putting serious effort into passing. TPT's 4-year track record, 4,500+ reviews, and consistent payouts win. I'd sacrifice the 15-min payout speed and cleaner LucidFlex rules for peace of mind.

If I'm a platform specialist (ATAS, EdgeClear, Sierra Chart power user):
→ TakeProfitTrader. Lucid doesn't support my tools. Non-negotiable.

If I'm a beginner (<6 months experience):
→ Neither. Demo trade for 3-6 months, journal every setup, build a system that works under pressure, THEN consider prop firms. TPT's 16.86% pass rate and Lucid's EOD+DLL will eat you alive if you're still figuring out risk management.

The Bottom Line

TakeProfitTrader and Lucid Trading are both legitimate futures prop firms with real payouts, but they serve completely different needs.

TPT = Safety, longevity, platform variety. Best for experienced traders who value 4-year track record, 15+ platform support, and no consistency rule in funded accounts. The PRO intraday drawdown filters undisciplined traders, but if you adapt, the 80/20 → 90/10 splits are solid. 36-48hr payouts are acceptable if you're not desperate for speed.

Lucid = Speed, clean rules, LucidFlex revolution. Best for traders who value ~15 min payouts (fastest in industry), EOD drawdown everywhere, news trading freedom, and LucidFlex's no-DLL/no-consistency structure. One-time payment caps costs for slow learners. Higher firm risk due to <1 year track record, but the upside is massive if they survive.

Neither is "better"—they're tools for different jobs. Pick the one that matches your trading style, risk tolerance for firm age, platform needs, and payout speed requirements. And whatever you choose, understand the drawdown model BEFORE you start—that's what kills 70% of traders who fail.

If you pass TPT Test but get wrecked in PRO: Switch to Lucid LucidFlex. EOD drawdown will save you.

If you're nervous about Lucid's <1 year age: Start with TPT for safety, then branch into Lucid once you're comfortable.

If you want the absolute best rules right now: Lucid LucidFlex. Nothing else compares.

Your Next Steps

Start Trading at TakeProfitTrader →

Start Trading at Lucid Trading

Read the Complete TakeProfitTrader Review →