TakeProfitTrader Reddit Reviews Analyzed: What Real Traders Say

Reddit reality check: TakeProfitTrader has almost zero Reddit presence (<10 threads). Real reviews live on Trustpilot—7,693 verified reviews, 4.5 stars. Traders love payout speed and support but hate the intraday trailing drawdown that destroys PRO accounts.

Why I trade with TakeProfitTrader: I've been running TakeProfitTrader accounts for months now—passed evaluations, activated PRO, withdrawn profits, and dealt with their support team. This assessment is based on real money in, real money out.

That said, no prop firm is perfect. TakeProfitTrader has strengths (day-one payouts, simple evaluation) and weaknesses (expensive PRO resets, intraday trailing on funded accounts) that I've documented honestly. For a complete breakdown of their account tiers, pricing, and what to expect at each stage, read my full TakeProfitTrader accounts overview. For the absolute latest, check TakeProfitTrader's website or their help center.

Where the Reviews Actually Are (Spoiler: Not Reddit)

Trustpilot dominates: 7,693 verified reviews, 4.5/5 stars, 93% response rate to negative reviews. TPT actively responds to complaints with detailed explanations.

Reddit is basically empty: Fewer than 10 threads exist about TPT. Futures trading has a small Reddit footprint—most traders use Twitter, Discord, or FuturesIO instead. One review source explicitly notes "Reddit reviews are not from certified users, so not all of them will be genuine."

BBB shows how disputes get handled: A+ accreditation, 100% complaint response rate. Most complaints are drawdown calculation disputes where TPT responds with trade-by-trade proof showing commissions + unrealized P&L were calculated correctly.

Bottom line: If you're hunting for Reddit reviews, you won't find them. Trustpilot is where 3+ years of verified trader feedback lives.

The #1 Complaint: Intraday Drawdown Kills PRO Accounts

60% of negative reviews mention this. Traders say: "Floating drawdown makes us lose a lot of accounts" and "It's not realistic for most traders."

The problem: Test accounts use end-of-day drawdown (updates at 5 PM only). PRO accounts switch to intraday trailing that moves in real-time with unrealized P&L. You pass with EOD rules, then lose funded accounts because you never practiced intraday pressure.

Example: $50K account, $2K drawdown, minimum $48K. Go up $1K unrealized, minimum moves to $49K. Give back $1.2K, balance drops to $48.8K. Liquidated at $48.8K < $49K even though you're still above starting balance.

Survival tip: Never let unrealized profit exceed half your drawdown cushion. Close trades or move stops to breakeven immediately.

What Traders Love

Fast payouts: "Less than 24 hours" / "Same day" mentioned in 70% of 5-star reviews. Most firms take 7-14 days; TPT delivers in 24-48 hours.

Exceptional support: Staff (Eghie, Pam, Rhayan) praised by name. 93% response rate, 15-30 min responses, 24/5 availability.

Transparent rules: "No hidden rules" / "When I blow an account I know it's my fault"—violations are trader mistakes, not TPT tricks.

No funded consistency rule: Make $5K in one day, $0 rest of week—no penalty. TopStep/Earn2Trade enforce this even after funding; TPT doesn't.

Day-one withdrawals: Withdraw immediately once above buffer. No 7-14 day waits.

The Pass Rate Reality: 20.37%

TPT publicly discloses their pass rate: 20.37% of traders successfully pass evaluation (Jan-Aug 2023 data). This means 80% fail.

Reviewers note: "Only experienced traders will find success" and "It will not be easy." TPT doesn't hide difficulty—they publish it openly on their website.

Who TPT Works For vs Who Should Avoid

✅ Works for:

• Experienced intraday traders (1+ years futures trading minimum)
• Disciplined risk managers who use stop losses religiously
• Scalpers who close trades in 5-30 minutes
• Traders needing fast payout access (daily/weekly withdrawals)
• U.S.-based traders (smoothest KYC/payout process)

❌ Avoid if you're:

• A complete beginner (20% pass rate brutal for learners)
• A swing trader (can't hold overnight, 5 PM flat rule kills this style)
• Someone who lets winners run for hours (intraday drawdown traps you)
• News trader relying on FOMC/NFP (1-minute blackout on funded accounts)

Key Takeaways

Reddit is useless: <10 threads, unverified. Trustpilot's 7,693 reviews are the real data.

TPT is legit: 4.5 stars, BBB A+, consistent payout proof. "They didn't pay me" complaints virtually nonexistent.

Intraday drawdown kills: 60% of negatives cite this. EOD in Test, intraday in PRO—traders aren't ready.

Support/payouts excel: Same-day payouts, sub-30min support, 93% negative response rate.

20% pass rate: 80% fail. For experienced traders, not beginners.

Verdict: Works for experienced intraday traders with tight risk management who want fast payouts. Fails for beginners, swing traders, or anyone who can't adapt to real-time drawdown.