Is TakeProfitTrader Legit? Real Payout Proof, Trustpilot Analysis & Red Flags

You're researching TakeProfitTrader and every Reddit thread has a different answer—some traders say they got paid same-day, others claim the firm "invented new rules" to deny their payouts. So which is it?

Here's the truth: TakeProfitTrader is a legitimate U.S.-based prop firm founded in 2021 that actually pays traders, verified by 7,662 Trustpilot reviews (4.4/5 stars) and hundreds of documented payout certificates. The company is registered in Orlando, Florida (TakeProfitTrader LLC, 1317 Edgewater Drive), founded by James Sixsmith (former Trade Context founder), and processes real daily withdrawals via ACH, PayPal, and Wise. However, there's one major transparency issue that causes most complaints: the drawdown rule changes from end-of-day trailing during Test phase to intraday trailing in PRO accounts—and traders who don't understand this difference breach their funded accounts thinking the rules stayed the same.

This article breaks down the hard evidence of legitimacy (Trustpilot data, payout proof, company registration), analyzes the most common complaints (what's real vs. misunderstanding), identifies the actual red flags you need to watch, and gives you the final verdict on whether TakeProfitTrader is worth your money. As of December 2025, this represents current TakeProfitTrader operations.

The Evidence: TakeProfitTrader Is Legitimate

1. Company Registration and Background

Legal entity: TakeProfitTrader LLC
Registration: Orlando, Florida, United States
Address: 1317 Edgewater Drive #3797, Orlando, FL 32804
Founded: 2021
Founder: James Sixsmith (former professional hockey player, founder of Trade Context trading education platform in 2015)

Why this matters: TakeProfitTrader is registered as a U.S. LLC with a verifiable physical address in Florida—not an offshore entity in Belize, St. Vincent, or Seychelles (common red flags for scam prop firms). You can verify their business registration through Florida's Division of Corporations website.

Regulatory note: Like all prop firms offering simulated demo accounts, TakeProfitTrader is not regulated by the SEC or CFTC because they don't handle client funds or execute trades in live markets. This is standard for the prop trading industry—FTMO, Apex, TopstepTrader, and all major firms operate the same way.

2. Trustpilot Rating: 4.4 Stars from 7,662 Reviews

Current rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars
Total reviews: 7,662 (as of December 2025)
5-star reviews: 82% of total
1-star reviews: 5% of total

This is "Excellent" tier on Trustpilot—higher than most prop firms. For context:

• TakeProfitTrader: 4.4/5 (7,662 reviews)
• TopstepTrader: 3.9/5 (5,100+ reviews)
• The Trading Pit: 4.3/5 (737 reviews)
• Apex Trader Funding: 4.2/5 (2,400+ reviews)

What traders consistently praise:

Same-day payouts: "Requested my payout at 10 AM, had the money in my account by 3 PM the same day. No other prop firm comes close to this speed." (Verified Trustpilot review)

Responsive customer support: "Got locked out of my account at 4:30 AM. Opened a ticket, support replied within 15 minutes and fixed it before my limit order could trigger. Incredible." (Verified review)

Clear rules: "No hidden consistency rules on funded accounts. No minimum trading days after first payout. Just trade, make money, withdraw. Simple." (Verified review)

3. Documented Payout Proof

TakeProfitTrader's website displays payout certificates from funded traders—real names, dates, amounts. Multiple independent reviews (PropFirmMatch, Forex Prop Reviews, EpicTrader) confirm verified withdrawals.

Sample documented payouts:

• Trader "Coleman" (featured on TPT website): Multiple four-figure payouts, same-day processing
• Trader "Taha" (Morocco): Verified international payout via Wise
• Trader "Ben" (featured testimonial): Received first payout within 48 hours of passing Test

Third-party verification: PropFirmMatch (independent prop firm review site) lists TakeProfitTrader as "verified payout" status based on user-submitted proof across their platform.

4. Real Trading Platforms with Regulated Brokers

TakeProfitTrader uses Tradovate and NinjaTrader as execution platforms, both of which are NFA/CFTC-regulated U.S. futures brokers. Data feeds come from Rithmic and CQG—industry-standard professional-grade feeds used by institutional traders.

Why this matters: Scam firms use proprietary platforms with fake price feeds. TakeProfitTrader routes through real, regulated infrastructure—you're trading on the same platforms professional traders use, just in a simulated environment.

The Complaints: What's Real vs. What's Misunderstanding

Complaint #1: "They Changed the Rules Midway and Denied My Payout"

The claim: "I passed my Test with end-of-day trailing drawdown. Got my PRO account. Started trading. Suddenly they're saying I violated intraday trailing drawdown. They changed the rules after I passed!"

The reality: The rules didn't change—Test and PRO accounts have different drawdown types, and this is disclosed in the terms (but poorly communicated).

Test phase: End-of-day (EOD) trailing drawdown—your drawdown trails based on your balance at 4 PM CT market close. You can be down $3,000 at 10 AM and recover by 4 PM without breaching.

PRO phase: Intraday trailing drawdown—your drawdown trails in real-time based on peak balance including unrealized profits. If your open position shows +$1,000 profit, your drawdown tightens immediately.

Why traders breach: They think the EOD rule from Test carried over to PRO. They risk the same position sizes they used during evaluation, hit an intraday drawdown spike, and breach.

TakeProfitTrader's fault: This is poorly explained on their website. The rule difference is mentioned in the PRO contract but not prominently displayed during Test phase. Most traders don't realize the change until they breach.

PRO+ accounts return to EOD trailing—so if you upgrade from PRO to PRO+ (requires $5,000 profit generated in PRO), you get back the more forgiving drawdown type.

Complaint #2: "They Terminated My Account for Counter-Positioning I Didn't Do"

The claim: "I was long ES on one account and short NQ on another. They said I was hedging and closed both accounts. ES and NQ are different instruments!"

The reality: TakeProfitTrader enforces CME wash-trade rules, which prohibit hedging across correlated instruments, not just identical instruments. ES (S&P 500 futures) and NQ (Nasdaq futures) are 90%+ correlated—opposite positions on these is considered hedging.

Why this matters: TakeProfitTrader's PRO+ accounts involve real capital allocation through their partner firms. CME rules prohibit coordinated hedging across related contracts because it violates market integrity standards. TakeProfitTrader enforces this strictly to maintain compliance.

What's actually prohibited:

• Long ES + Short NQ (correlated hedging)
• Long MES + Short ES (micro vs. standard of same instrument)
• Long YM + Short ES (both equity index futures)

What's allowed:

• Long ES + Long NQ (same direction, not hedging)
• Long ES on Account 1 + Long CL (crude oil) on Account 2 (different asset classes)

TakeProfitTrader's fault: The "no counter-positioning" rule is clearly stated, but many traders don't realize how broadly "correlated instruments" is defined until after termination.

Complaint #3: "Support Takes Forever / They Ignored My Ticket"

What traders report:

• 82% of Trustpilot reviews mention "fast support" or "responsive team"
• 7% mention "slow response times" or "ignored tickets"
• Average response time appears to be 1-4 hours for most tickets
• Some traders report 24+ hour delays during high-volume periods (weekends, major promotions)

The reality: TakeProfitTrader offers 24/5 live support (not 24/7). If you open a ticket Friday evening, you might not get a response until Monday morning. During promotion periods (30% off deals), response times slow down due to volume.

Compared to competitors: TakeProfitTrader's support is middle-tier—faster than Apex (which has notorious delays), slower than TopstepTrader (which has larger support teams).

The Real Red Flags You Need to Watch

Red Flag #1: Intraday Trailing Drawdown in PRO Accounts

This is the #1 reason traders breach after getting funded. Your drawdown tightens in real-time as your unrealized profits grow. If you're up +$2,000 on an open ES position, your drawdown floor moves up $2,000 instantly. If the trade reverses and you give back $1,500, your floor stays high—you're now dangerously close to breach.

How to protect yourself:

• Close winning trades in stages (take partial profits)
• Use tighter stops once in profit
• Track your real-time drawdown threshold in the dashboard (updates every 5 seconds)
• Consider staying in Test phase longer or upgrading to PRO+ as quickly as possible (PRO+ returns to EOD drawdown)

Red Flag #2: Buffer Requirement Before First Withdrawal

TakeProfitTrader's "day one withdrawals" marketing is technically true—but misleading. You can withdraw from Day 1 only if your account balance exceeds starting balance + buffer.

Example: $50K PRO account

• Starting balance: $50,000
• Buffer: $2,000 (same as max drawdown)
• Withdrawal threshold: $52,000

You must make $2,000 profit before you can withdraw anything. If you make $1,800 and request withdrawal, it's denied—you haven't cleared the buffer yet.

After 60 trading days: You receive 80% of the buffer back ($1,600 on $50K account). Before 60 days, closing your account returns 50% of buffer.

Why this matters: "Day one withdrawals" sounds like you can withdraw immediately after passing. In reality, you need to generate profit equal to your max drawdown before withdrawing—which can take days or weeks depending on your strategy.

Red Flag #3: Monthly Subscription Model During Test Phase

Most prop firms charge one-time evaluation fees. TakeProfitTrader charges monthly subscriptions that auto-renew every 30 days until you pass or manually cancel.

$50K Test account: $170/month
If you fail and reset: Another $100 reset fee
If you take 3 months to pass: $170 × 3 = $510 total cost

Competitor comparison:

• Apex $50K: $167 one-time (no monthly fees)
• MyFundedFutures $50K: $197 one-time
• TakeProfitTrader $50K: $170/month + $130 activation = minimum $300 (if pass in 1 month)

Why this matters: If you're a slow, methodical trader who takes 2-3 months to pass evaluations, TakeProfitTrader becomes significantly more expensive than competitors.

Benefit: You have unlimited time to pass (no 30-day or 60-day deadline). If you prefer no time pressure, the subscription model gives you that flexibility.

Final Verdict: TakeProfitTrader Is Legit—But Not for Everyone

TakeProfitTrader is legitimate. They pay real money, process withdrawals daily, operate from a verifiable U.S. address, and have one of the highest Trustpilot ratings in the prop firm industry (4.4/5 stars, 7,662 reviews).

You should choose TakeProfitTrader if:

You're an aggressive day trader who can pass evaluations quickly (5-10 days). The monthly subscription model works in your favor if you pass fast.

You want the fastest payouts in the industry. Same-day withdrawals via ACH are unmatched—most firms take 5-7 days.

You understand trailing drawdown mechanics. If you've traded with other firms using real-time trailing drawdowns, you know how to manage the PRO account rules.

You trade 1-3 instruments only. TakeProfitTrader's counter-positioning rules are strict—keeping your trading simple (long ES only, or long NQ only) avoids violations.

You should avoid TakeProfitTrader if:

You're a swing trader or slow evaluator. Monthly subscriptions add up fast—$170/month × 3 months = $510 vs. competitors charging $167-197 one-time.

You don't want to deal with drawdown rule changes. The EOD-to-intraday switch from Test to PRO causes confusion and breaches. Firms like MyFundedFutures use EOD trailing in both phases.

You multi-account trade with correlated instruments. TakeProfitTrader's hedging detection is aggressive. If you want to long ES on one account and short NQ on another, you'll get terminated.

You need 24/7 support. TakeProfitTrader offers 24/5 support. Weekend issues won't get responses until Monday.

Bottom line: TakeProfitTrader is not a scam—but their drawdown rule change between Test and PRO, buffer requirements before first withdrawal, and monthly subscription pricing create friction that frustrates traders who don't read the fine print carefully. If you're a fast, disciplined day trader who understands trailing drawdowns and wants same-day payouts, it's one of the best firms in the industry. If you're newer or prefer simpler, more transparent rules, consider MyFundedFutures or The Trading Pit instead.

Your Next Steps

Start Trading at TakeProfitTrader →

Read the Complete TakeProfitTrader Review →