Alpha Futures vs Topstep: Which Futures Prop Firm Wins in 2026?

Alpha Futures is the UK-based newcomer that launched in July 2024 and immediately differentiated itself with a feature no other futures prop firm offers: the Daily Loss Guard.

Instead of terminating your account when you hit the daily loss limit, Alpha locks your account for the rest of the trading day and lets you try again tomorrow. Compare that to most firms where a daily loss breach means account death, and you start understanding why Alpha has attracted experienced traders who've been burned by rigid rules. Topstep approaches daily risk differently—they don't enforce a mandatory daily loss limit at all, letting traders set their own through TopstepX's risk tools.

Both approaches have merit, but they serve fundamentally different trader psychologies. I've tested both firms, and the choice comes down to whether you want external guardrails that protect you from yourself (Alpha) or the freedom to manage your own risk within an EOD trailing drawdown framework (Topstep).

How I compare firms: This comparison is built from actual accounts I've evaluated and traded with each firm—not from reading marketing pages or aggregating reviews. I've run evaluations, tested platforms, analyzed rule differences, and tracked real payout data across both firms.

Topstep pioneered futures prop trading and remains the benchmark every other firm gets measured against. For the full breakdown of their account structure, pricing, rules, and what makes them different from newer futures firms, check out my complete Topstep review. It's based on real evaluation experience and honest analysis—including what works, what doesn't, and where newer competitors have caught up. For the absolute latest, check Topstep's website or their Help Center.

"

Account Types: Three Tiers vs One Model

Topstep's single Trading Combine evaluation works the same for all traders: 6% profit target, 4% EOD trailing drawdown, 50% consistency, any account size.

Alpha Futures offers three distinct account tiers with meaningfully different economics.

The Standard plan ($79/month for 50K) is the entry-level option: 6% profit target, 4% EOD trailing drawdown, 2% Daily Loss Guard, 50% eval consistency / 40% funded consistency. Profit split starts at 70% and scales to 80% after your second payout, then 90% after your fifth. Bi-weekly payouts. $149 activation fee.

The Advanced plan ($139/month for 50K) removes the tiered profit split—you get flat 90% from day one. Weekly payouts (after 5 winning days of $200+). $149 activation fee. Same drawdown and Daily Loss Guard rules.

The Zero plan ($99/month for 50K) eliminates the activation fee entirely. Flat 90% profit split from day one. Weekly payouts. The trade-off: only available in 50K and 100K sizes (no 150K option).

The tiered structure gives traders genuine choice. Budget-conscious beginners take Standard and accept the lower initial profit split. Confident traders pay more for Advanced/Zero and get 90% immediately with faster payout cycles.

The Daily Loss Guard: Alpha's Defining Feature

This is the single most important innovation in this comparison, and it deserves thorough explanation.

At every other prop firm, hitting the daily loss limit means one of two things: your account is terminated (hard breach), or your account is paused and you lose trading privileges for the day with a possible violation on your record. At Alpha Futures, hitting the 2% Daily Loss Guard locks your account until the next trading session. No termination. No violation. No strike. You just can't trade anymore today.

Why this matters: the daily loss limit is the second most common reason traders lose funded accounts (after max trailing drawdown). It often happens on volatile days—FOMC announcements, surprise economic data, flash crashes—when traders are caught in fast moves and can't exit in time. At most firms, this single event ends your funded career. At Alpha, you come back tomorrow and continue trading as if nothing happened.

The psychological impact is significant. Knowing your account survives a bad day changes how you manage risk. You're less likely to panic-exit at the worst price because you know the account lives even if you breach the daily limit. You can focus on position management rather than account survival.

Topstep's approach is different but also trader-friendly: they don't enforce a mandatory daily loss limit. TopstepX lets you optionally set your own daily loss, profit target, and trade count limits—but you choose whether to activate them. No automatic enforcement means no daily breach risk from the firm's side. The only breach risk is the overall EOD trailing drawdown.

My take: Alpha's Daily Loss Guard is better for traders who lack self-discipline on bad days. Topstep's self-imposed limits are better for traders who want maximum flexibility and trust themselves to manage risk independently. Alpha protects you from yourself. Topstep trusts you to protect yourself.

Profit Split: Topstep Wins Early, Alpha Wins Late (Zero Plan)

For new traders on Alpha's Standard plan, the 70% initial split is the worst in the industry for futures prop firms. On $5,000 in payouts, you keep $3,500—versus $4,500 at Topstep (90/10). That's $1,000 less during the most critical early phase.

The Standard plan only reaches 90% after your fifth payout. If you're generating $2,000/month in payouts, that's 2.5 months of earning 10-20% less than Topstep traders.

Alpha's Zero plan fixes this entirely—90% flat from day one with no activation fee. At $99/month evaluation cost (versus Topstep's $49 + $149 activation), the Zero plan is cost-competitive when you factor in the eliminated activation fee. For traders who know they want 90% from the start, Zero is the right choice.

The math over 6 months of funded trading (assuming $3,000/month in withdrawals):

Topstep: ($49 + $149 startup) + (90% × $3,000 × 6) = $198 cost + $16,200 payouts = $16,002 net.

Alpha Zero: ($99 startup) + (90% × $3,000 × 6) = $99 cost + $16,200 payouts = $16,101 net.

Alpha Standard: ($79 + $149 startup) + tiered split averaging ~82% × $3,000 × 6 = $228 cost + $14,760 payouts = $14,532 net.

Alpha Zero narrowly beats Topstep over 6 months. Standard loses significantly due to the tiered split. The plan you choose within Alpha matters enormously.

Platform Migration: Alpha's Growing Ecosystem

Alpha Futures phased out ProjectX in February 2026 and now offers AlphaTicks (their custom Quantower-based platform), Tradovate, and NinjaTrader. This gives Alpha traders access to professional-grade charting, order flow analysis, and the full NinjaTrader indicator ecosystem.

Topstep offers TopstepX exclusively—proprietary platform with TradingView charts, commission-free execution, and built-in risk tools.

For traders with platform-specific workflows (NinjaTrader indicators, Tradovate mobile trading, Quantower volume analysis), Alpha's flexibility is a clear advantage. For traders who want the simplest possible setup with no commissions, TopstepX is self-contained and cost-effective.

Automatic Evaluation Resets

Alpha provides unlimited evaluation time with automatic resets on each monthly rebill. Blow your account mid-month? It resets when your next subscription payment processes. No separate reset fee. No manual request required.

Topstep's evaluation resets happen differently—your account continues as long as you're subscribed, and a new subscription month effectively functions as a fresh start if you've breached. The mechanics are similar, but Alpha's framing is more explicit about the automatic reset.

For traders who expect multiple attempts to pass (most should), the automatic reset with no additional fee is a cost advantage over firms that charge $75-$150 per reset.

Trust and Track Record

Topstep: 14 years, Chicago-based, 11,500+ Trustpilot reviews, industry pioneer.

Alpha Futures: Founded July 2024, UK-based, 4.9 Trustpilot rating. Significantly newer. The UK registration provides some regulatory framework comfort compared to unregulated offshore firms, but Alpha is a prop firm, not a regulated broker—the same caveat applies to Topstep and every other firm in this space.

The 4.9 Trustpilot rating at reasonable review volume is strong, but a firm founded in mid-2024 simply hasn't been tested by time. Topstep has survived everything the market has thrown at it for over a decade.

Education and Community

Topstep's TopstepTV, Training Camp, and 72K+ Discord are unmatched. Alpha Futures offers community Discord and educational content, but nothing approaching Topstep's depth or daily engagement.

The Verdict

Choose Alpha Futures if you: need the Daily Loss Guard protection (account survives bad days), want platform flexibility (NinjaTrader/Tradovate/AlphaTicks), prefer the Zero plan's combination of no activation fee + 90% flat split, appreciate automatic evaluation resets on rebill, trade volatile instruments where daily loss protection saves accounts, and want 40% funded consistency instead of 50%.

Choose Topstep if you: prioritize 14-year track record, prefer no daily loss limit at all (self-managed risk), want commission-free execution, value daily coaching via TopstepTV, prefer lower monthly evaluation cost ($49 vs $79-$99), and want the simplest possible evaluation structure.

The honest synthesis: Alpha Futures' Daily Loss Guard is the most innovative risk management feature in futures prop trading right now. For traders who've lost funded accounts to bad-day blowups—and that's most of us at some point—the ability to survive daily loss breaches and come back tomorrow is genuinely game-changing. Topstep's no-DLL approach with EOD trailing drawdown is also excellent, just different in philosophy. Alpha is the protector; Topstep is the liberator. Both work. Your temperament determines which fits better. If you tend to revenge-trade on bad days, pick Alpha—the Daily Loss Guard will save you from yourself. If you trust your discipline and want maximum freedom, pick Topstep.

‍